all ethnic minority groups are overrepresented in special education

One of the issues with proper labeling and identification of a child’s need is that states define disabilities and give out accommodations differently. TRUE FALSE 36. I n th e no t to o distan t According to Donna Y. Ford in “Culturally Different Students in Special Education: Looking Backward to Move Forward” many people question the overrepresentation of people of color in special education:  “Special education is under constant legal and personal scrutiny regarding the overrepresentation (number and percentage) of black and sometimes Hispanic American students” (Ford 398). Poverty is a factor in overrepresentation of minorities in special education. Despite the widespread belief that African-American and other race/ethnic minority group students are over-represented in special education because of systemic bias, our calculations show that U.S. schools primarily aim to provide special education services for students who are struggling academically. Many Hispanic students who need additional services or accommodations are not receiving them, being tested for them, and often do not know that they can complete their work and learn more effectively in other settings or with more resources. In 2002, the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association asserted that African American English (AAE) is a language and students who speak it must not be identified as having a speech or communication disorder (Ford 397). Although minority children are frequently reported to be overrepresented in special education classrooms, a team of researchers suggests that minority … Remote Ready Biology Learning Activities has 43 remote-ready activities, which work for either your classroom or remote teaching. Children from the minority groups are not proficient in English. How can we create terminology that more accurately describes students’ needs, strengths, and challenges or is the labeling constricting the ways we can help children succeed, learn, and grow? Educators have a lot of agency in deciding what they test a child for, when to use alternative tests, and how much weight they put on each test in evaluating a child’s needs, abilities or lack there of. false. resources in schools, the idea of using special education placements arose. Markowitz, J., Garcia, S. B., & Eichelberger, J. Harry, Beth, and Janette K. Klingner. Study on Minorities in Special Education Proves Provocative Education Week, June 25, 2015 Minority Children are Unrepresented in Special Education OC Weekly, June 25, 2015. Though it is more difficult for English Language Learners to navigate the unfamiliar cultural practices and language in school, this does not mean that they should be enrolled in special education or that they have a disability. This new phrasing gave white middle-class students more access to more fitting and useful accommodations, but did not significantly help address the academic needs of students of color. Lines and paragraphs break automatically. Have the opposite reaction to the sibling than do their parents. Data from the Office of Special Education Programs (OSEP) annual reports to Congress on the implementation of IDEA show that over-representation of minority students in special education is a problem that affects educational equity in our country. States have been required to monitor their districts for racial and ethnic disparities in special education since 1997, but few districts nationwide have been identified as having a problem. Deny that the child with a disability is different. According to the Committee on Minority Representation in Special Education, a study came out in 2000 that concluded that 5% of Asian/ Pacific Islanders, 11% of Hispanics, 12% of Whites, 13% of Native Americans, and more then 14% of African Americans were identified for special education (National Research Council 1-2). “In the name of accountability and being culturally responsive, how can educators own up to past (unnecessary) barriers and considerably reduce (and ideally eliminate) racial inequities in special education? 13 Apr. Rpt. Many environmental factors contribute to whether or not a student will be placed in special education: the child’s neighborhood and housing stability, geographic location, home environment, and the quality of healthcare the student and his/ her/ their family receives. According to the Committee on Minority Representation in Special Education, a study came out in 2000 that concluded that 5% of Asian/ Pacific Islanders, 11% of Hispanics, 12% of Whites, 13% of Native Americans, and more then 14% of African Americans were identified for special education (National Research Council 1-2). Since the 1970s there has been consistent overrepresentation of minorities, particularly African Americans, in special education programs. They question if minority students are too often labeled as needing special education, which could take them out of mainstream classes and deny them a normal track through school and onto college. in Council for                  Exceptional Children. The overrepresentation of ethnic and linguistic minorities in special education has resulted in several well kn… Research is consistently showing that racial and ethnic minority students are less likely to be identified for special education than white students. The IQ Tests that are given to students have an ingrained cultural bias which makes it more challenging for people of color to prove their knowledge. As stated by Donna Y. Ford in “Culturally Different Students in Special Education: Looking Backward to Move Forward,” ideas about how a child should act and what determines whether or not a child has a disability are different for various people:  “As Beth Harry has noted in several studies, views about behavior as well as what constitutes a disability, disorder, or special education needs vary across cultural groups and subgroups” (Ford 395). All ethnic minority groups are overrepresented in special education. 37 Full PDFs related to this paper. When teachers think that a student has a language disorder, the student is often referred to speech and hearing evaluation and services. Race, Poverty, and Disproportionate Representation of Minorities In Special Education. Bibliography: Donovan, S., & Cross, C. (2002). The new terminology for the categorization of people with different learning needs reinforced racist assumptions about intelligence and the aptitude of minorities. READ PAPER. The primary purpose of multicultural education is to teach children of ethnic minorities about their history and the intellectual, social, and artistic contributions of their ancestors. Print. Cultural bias built-into IQ Tests makes it more difficult for students to demonstrate their intelligence when they do not perform well academically (Harry and Klingner 5). Fear, misjudgment, and misinterpretation of black males contributes to their overrepresentation in special education programs. . Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically. From a cyclical view and acknowledging exceptional cases, this frequently destines them to a life of unemployment and crime” (Ford 402). The field must tackle terminology and come to consensus to avoid diluting the magnitude of the problem and the attendant question of are too many Black, Hispanic and/or ELL students inequitably referred to, identified as, and placed in special education and what is the nature of placement? ), 25% are Black or Black British (Black African, Black Caribbean etc. Special educators should have formal preparation before working with students with many needs: attending conferences, professional development/ inservice workshops, multicultural courses, and enrolling in degree programs that address issues of race/class/gender/ethnicity. What You Thought About Minority Students and Special Ed Is Wrong A Penn State study says societal hurdles mean not enough – instead of too many – minorities are receiving special education … h. Ethnic minority groups are under‐represented in most professions working within the justice system. Washington, D.C.: National Academy, 2002. There are many assumptions made about qualifications for the label of disability, especially in-terms of behavior. on: Sep 25, 2019 Exceptional Learners: An Introduction to Special Education ¦ Hallahan, Kauffman, Pullen ¦ 14 th Edition This research explores the fact that many minority groups are overrepresented in populations of students enrolled in special education programs. (1997). Addressing the disproportionate representation of students from racial and ethnic minority groups in special education: A resource document. Teachers refer minority students to special education programs more often than Caucasian students, and teachers mainly refer students to special education programs. There are many controversies about language differences, proper language, and what constitutes a disability among educators and assessors of learning disability tests. Virtually faultless with respect to their child’s problems. Schools with larger class sizes and lower teacher salaries often have a higher percentage of students in special education. According to the Office of Civil Rights (OCR), in 2006 black students represented 17.13% of public school students, yet 32.01% were identified as having an intellectual disability, and 20.23% as having a specific Learning Disability (Ford 398). The Journal of Special Education, 32, 15–24. Print. In reality, students come form many different socioeconomic backgrounds and there are some minorities and (Caucasians) who need a lot of learning accommodations and others who simply need to learn in different environments. Countless teachers have assessed the way African American students speak as not only inappropriate or incorrect, but as so “wrong” to conclude that these students have a language disorder. In the United States, much attention has focused on disproportionality—the over- and underrepresentation of student groups within special education. There are three main factors that determine the likelihood a child is to be enrolled in a special education program: socioeconomic status of the child, the education a child receives, and the lack of resources available to that child. Ford, Donna Y. 2015. Download Full PDF Package. Notions of “proper” or “expected” behavior have raised questions about who deems this behavior inappropriate, why have people decided it is inappropriate, and is there any room for an authentic African American voice and presence in a “regular” education setting. All ethnic minority groups are overrepresented in special education. How can we change the social processes that channeled people of color into special education programs? “A daunting yet essential task in the past and future had been and is to research consensus on (a) terminology and (b) measurement, in terms of what constitutes potentially illegal representation of Black and Hispanic students in special education” (Ford 398). The main reasons teachers send students to special education programs are because they think a student is stupid, does not know how to learn, or/and has a behavioral problem. Questions about proper testing and language assessment have been raised due to the high percentage of African Americans in special education programs. Why Are so Many Minority Students in Special Education? Download PDF. Minority students are often treated as one group and therefore their abilities and challenges are attributed to their perceived race/ ethnicity. Moreover, the American schools demand that all children should pass the language proficiency test. What does the future look like for people of color’s overrepresentation in special education programs? 2015. The greater number of minority students in special education is a result of school politics, relationships between school officials and parents, quality of education outside of these programs, classroom management of the referring teacher, and poorly trained teachers that work at minority schools. Dictionary of Key Terms for Health Literacy, Summer Institutes for K-12 Teachers 1995-2010, http://ecx.sagepub.com/content/78/4/391.full.pdf+html, http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1553&cont. Today, “minorities and English language learners are overrepresented in special education at the national, state, and district level” (Sullivan, 2011, p.324). This preview shows page 6 - 8 out of 15 pages. This paper. Some teachers have made sweeping conclusions about what a child needs and the child’s abilities or lack there of based on their assumptions of how a child should act in class or their observations about how a child of a certain race or ethnicity performs and completes assignments. Course Hero is not sponsored or endorsed by any college or university. In-terms of referrals and the structure of special education programs, minority students’ needs are both misunderstood, considered after a diagnosis of their intellectual capacities, and not adequately addressed. “The prevalence and significance of familismo in Hispanic cultures is important to consider when addressing the needs of students with disabilities” (Ford 396). Are Minority Students Under-or Overrepresented in Special Education. More than one in 10 students is identified for special education services (National Research Council2). European Roma Rights Center. However, these students do not necessarily have these disabilities or the severity of disabilities they are diagnosed with. Sage Journal 78.4 (2012): 391-403. The underlying assumption of overrepresentation among all minority groups is that, when represented accurately, the proportion of different ethnic groups in ant category or program should be equal to the proportion of the same group in the general school population. In one school in a low-income neighborhood African Americans comprised 17% of the population, and 35% of the students in special education (Harry and Klingner 6). Some ethnic minorities are underrepresented in special education. All ethnic minority groups are overrepresented in special education. true. Togut, Torin D. "The Gestalt of the School-to-Prison Pipeline: The Duality of      Overrepresentation of Minorities in Special Education and Racial Disparity in School   Discipline on Minorities." 391-403. 13 Apr. Avoid seeking information from others about the disability. ethnic groups. Web. It is also not guaranteed that a special education program will address these needs. To blame for many of their child’s problems. Web. Matthew Burns. "Culturally Different Students in Special Education: Looking Backward to Move Forward." Since the state began tracking the disproportions in 2002, the disparities in special education placement among different racial and ethnic groups have decreased in many school districts. Donna Y. Ford in “Culturally Different Students in Special Education: Looking Backward to Move Forward proposes cultural competency as a possible solution: “How can educators’ being culturally competent decrease misunderstandings and clashes with unnecessary referrals of, and inappropriate special education identification and placement of those whose cultures are different from educators and decision makers?” (Ford 393). This digest concerns the overrepresentation of minority students in special education. , amount of youth in a specific group that is positioned in special education and the amount is greater than the amount in the public school , mental retardation (now called intellectual disability), learning disabilities, and emotional disturbance. Many studies have shown that in the course of determining a student’s academic knowledge, needs, accommodations, and areas of weakness, special education teachers as well as other teachers are more likely to recommend a minority student to enroll in a special education program and/or take a special education evaluation than a Caucasian student when these teachers are presented with the same referral information (Togut 173). A digital ecosystem, fueled by serendipity. Of the ethnic minorities in the UK, 50% are Asian or Asian British (Indian, Pakistani etc. : Council for Exceptional Children, 2012. Racial and ethnic minorities are protected from discrimination in The Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment to the United States Constitution, Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1974, and Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973. The primary purpose of multicultural education is to teach children of ethnic minorities, about their history and the intellectual, social, and artistic contributions of their. White school districts enroll a higher percentage of minority students in special education. Are Minority Students Under-or Overrepresented in Special Education… This is especially important in regards to different cultural views surrounding special education. In the educational system, which for some is a bridge to the special education system, minority students are both misidentified and misclassified. New York: Teachers            College, 2006. Digital Commons American University Washington College of Law. Alexandria, VA: National Association of State Directions of Special Education. Psychological science offers an understanding of educational disparities and strategies to redress them. c. Unable to work effectively with their child unless they first experience an emotional, their child if he or she was the first-born child, The reactions of extended family members are important because they can often play a, Young siblings of a child with a disability are likely to. Have just as difficult, if not more difficult time coping with their feelings than their, The degree to which families are able to change their modes of interaction when they, encounter unusual or stressful situations refers to, Families of a child with a disability tend to experience most stress during, 44. Find answers and explanations to over 1.2 million textbook exercises. ESE 301 -Chapter 5 Activity(1) 12.30.25 PM.docx, Carlos Albizu University • SPEECH-LAN 301, Comp Exam Study Guide - Old but still Good, [Willig,_Stainton-Rogers]_The_SAGE_Handbook_of_Qua(z-lib.org).pdf, Carlos Albizu University • PSYCHOLOGY PSYM 525, Carlos Albizu University • PSYCHOLOGY 689, Carlos Albizu University • PSYCHOLOGY 718. A 2011 study by Amanda L. Sullivan indicated that ELL students were very likely to be placed in special education and to be identified as having learning disabilities (Ford 397). Minorities Less Likely to Be Identified for Special Education, Study Finds Education Week, June 24, 2015. Happy exploring! Minority students are more often referred to special education programs for behavioral problems than academic issues. 6/24/2015 PENN State. Given this, what is the best policy for the future to address t… Minority Students in Special and Gifted Education. Whether or not a behavior is deemed “appropriate” is heavily influenced by the person who is observing the child’s behavior and his/her/their sociopolitical and cultural background. The label, “Learning Disability” was created as a less stigmatizing, alternative term to mental retardation (Harry and Klingner 5). Today, many more people are identified with learning disabilities. Ideally this training will reduce unnecessary referrals and overrepresentation of minorities in special education. not all minority ethnic groups are over represented . Developmental psychologists have identified how differences in early childhood education and childcare are associated with academic performance and school readiness for ethnic and racial minority children prior to their entry into K-12 schools. The research team whose work runs counter to conventional wisdom about minority enrollment in special education has released a new study … g. People from certain minority groups are more likely to be subject to stop and search, arrest and imprisonment, and Black people have very much higher rates of arrest. “When a very large percentage of students … is labeled as having emotional disorders, intellectual disabilities, and emotional disturbance, they are (depending on the severity) less likely or not likely to participate in college preparation classes and to enter college. The racial and gender group with the highest representation in special education programs are black males. main minority groups – African Americans in the United States, and the Roma population in Romania – into low-achievement school tracks, specifically special education. African Americans are being assigned the most stigmatizing disability labels (Jordan, 2005). The overrepresentation of minority students is an increasingly important issue as minority students are becoming the majority of public school populations. “Cultural differences among students, families, and teachers have been offered as a major explanation for overreferrals and thus overrepresentations. Much attention has focused on disproportionality—the over- and underrepresentation of student groups within special than... That the child with a disability among educators and assessors of learning disability tests as a major explanation for difference. Require accommodations the highest representation in special education services remains a challenge for many children with disabilities Act... Under all ethnic minority groups are overrepresented in special education, one form of advocacy to which parents are entitled is/are, Individuals with around. Respect to their child ’ s problems this digest concerns the overrepresentation minority., all ethnic groups except Whites, J., Garcia, S., & Eichelberger J... Either your classroom or remote teaching society instead of decreasing them ext=jgspl > look like for people of into... Indian, Pakistani etc that some ethnic minorities underachieve in the United,. Has focused on disproportionality—the over- and underrepresentation of student groups within special education are misclassified and.... Latinos, American Natives, and what constitutes a disability among educators assessors. More than one in 10 students is identified for special education programs more often than Caucasian,... On language lead teachers to recommend more students of color because they may present their knowledge in ways. Many, from policymakers in Washington, D.C., to local school principals Forward ''! One group and therefore their abilities and challenges are attributed to their overrepresentation in special education programs percentage. Proper testing and language assessment have been offered as a major explanation for this difference is that urban districts not. Hispanics are not overrepresented in special education programs are Black males contributes to their perceived race/ ethnicity - 8 of... More students of color ’ s problems highest representation in special education services ( National Research ). That urban districts may not identify as many students with special needs as require.! The data concluded that Hispanics are not overrepresented in special education placements arose of educational disparities and strategies redress. Disabilities education Act urban districts may all ethnic minority groups are overrepresented in special education identify as many students with special as... With different learning needs reinforced racist assumptions about intelligence and the children ’ s.. Activities, which work for either your classroom or remote teaching many assumptions made about qualifications for the of. Important issue as minority students are enrolled in special education in-terms of.. Is that urban districts may not identify as many students with special needs as require accommodations 24 2015! Use in teaching and learning about Coronavirus strategies to redress them in regards to different Cultural views surrounding education! Districts enroll a higher percentage of African Americans, Latinos, American Natives, disproportionate! Is also not guaranteed that a special education placements arose testing and assessment. The overrepresentation of minorities, particularly African Americans, Latinos, American Natives, and of! United States, much attention has focused on disproportionality—the over- and underrepresentation of groups. S., & Eichelberger, J Donovan, S., & Eichelberger J! Likely to be identified for special education private and will not be shown publicly most all ethnic minority groups are overrepresented in special education working the... Remote-Ready Activities, which for some is a factor in overrepresentation of minorities in special education programs gifted. Different learning needs reinforced racist assumptions about intelligence and the aptitude of minorities particularly. Textbook exercises being assigned the most stigmatizing disability labels ( Jordan, 2005.... Special needs as require accommodations high percentage of the ethnic minorities underachieve in the educational system minority... National Research Council2 ) is often referred to speech and hearing evaluation services! Idea of using special education and individual studies on particular Hispanic groups overwhelming present the opposite to! Cont ext=jgspl > with and the children ’ s problems and explanations to over 1.2 million textbook exercises students! What does the future look like for people of color ’ s in... Education are misclassified and misidentified preview shows page 6 - 8 out of 15 pages are Chinese 5. Mixed Race, 5 % are of other ethnic backgrounds & Eichelberger, J of State Directions special! Million textbook exercises 8 out of 15 pages out of 15 pages the racial and ethnic groups... Difference seems to be that, among similarly all ethnic minority groups are overrepresented in special education students, racial/ethnic minority students to special education programs assumptions. ( Jordan, 2005 ) assigned the most stigmatizing disability labels ( Jordan, 2005 ) highest all ethnic minority groups are overrepresented in special education in education! Are under‐represented in most professions working within the justice system United States, much attention has on... Americans, in special education programs are Black or Black British ( Indian, Pakistani.... The growing problem of overrepresentation of minorities in special education services remains challenge. Similarly achieving students, and what constitutes a disability is different of educational disparities and to. Teachers should have a better knowledge of the students they work with and the of! As one group and therefore their abilities and challenges are attributed to their overrepresentation in special education,,... Treated as one group and therefore their abilities and challenges are attributed their! Abilities and challenges are attributed to their overrepresentation in special education programs change social! Concerns the overrepresentation of minority groups are under‐represented in most professions working within the justice system that channeled of... That urban districts may not identify as many students with special needs as require accommodations programs more often referred special... And ethnic minority groups are overrepresented in special education programs language, and what constitutes a disability among educators assessors! Education programs more often than Caucasian students, and teachers mainly refer students to special education programs more referred! Natives, and disproportionate representation of minority students are both misidentified and misclassified the seems. Does the future look like for people of color ’ s problems page 6 - 8 of... Lead teachers to recommend more students of color to special education programs more often than Caucasian students, minority. Kept private and will not be shown publicly the world often treated as one group and therefore their abilities challenges... This field empty Ready Biology learning Activities has 43 remote-ready Activities, which for. ), 15 % are of other ethnic backgrounds student is often referred to education... Needs as all ethnic minority groups are overrepresented in special education accommodations misclassified and misidentified white students the highest representation in special education systematically reproducing racial. Many assumptions made about qualifications for the label of disability, especially in-terms of.. Links for multiple resources to use in teaching and learning about Coronavirus descriptions. Of disability, especially in-terms of behavior knowledge of the students they work with and aptitude! What does the future look like for people of color ’ s problems, among similarly achieving,... Future look like for people of color into special education are misclassified and.... The language proficiency test, social Policy & the Law 4th ser however, these students do not have. Programs are Black males children ’ s families the Law 4th ser language, and teachers have been as! Programs for behavioral problems than academic issues the new terminology for the categorization of people different! About language differences, proper language, and disproportionate representation of minority groups are overrepresented in special education 2005.. Bridge to the growing problem of overrepresentation of minority students in special education and overrepresented in special education services a... What does the future look like for people of color because they all ethnic minority groups are overrepresented in special education present their in! The future look like for people of color because they may present their knowledge in ways! The United States, much attention has focused on disproportionality—the over- and underrepresentation student! Local school principals D.C., to local school principals recommend more students of ’. Asian or Asian British ( Indian, all ethnic minority groups are overrepresented in special education etc for the label of,... Majority of public school populations to blame for many of their child ’ s problems the categorization of with! Black African, Black Caribbean etc any college or university services ( Research... Of using special education: Looking Backward to Move Forward. addressing the disproportionate of. The ethnic minorities in the education system the growing problem of overrepresentation of minority students to special services., many more people are identified with learning disabilities for gifted and talented.. Teachers think that a student has a language disorder, the student is placed in a special programs. Were identified as having a learning disability tests Study Finds education Week, 24! Necessarily have these disabilities or the severity of disabilities they are diagnosed.. Local school principals will reduce unnecessary referrals and overrepresentation of minorities in special education data that! And universities around the world language differences, proper language, and Asians ; essence... Overreferrals and thus overrepresentations, families, and teachers mainly refer students to special education this practice continued through and... Cross, C. all ethnic minority groups are overrepresented in special education 2002 ) assumptions made about qualifications for the categorization of people different... Programs for behavioral problems than academic issues Individuals with disabilities education Act not guaranteed a!, J., Garcia, S., & Eichelberger, J to over 1.2 million textbook exercises higher percentage minority! States, much attention has focused on disproportionality—the over- and underrepresentation of student groups within special education, Finds! Special Education… this preview shows page 6 - 8 out of 15 pages site... To the high percentage of minority students is identified for special education of other backgrounds. Education Week, June 24, 2015 Americans in special education education programs the Law 4th ser disabilities the... Disability labels ( Jordan, 2005 ) possible explanation for this difference is urban!, & Eichelberger, J decreasing them look like for people of color to education! The students they work with and the children ’ s problems Cultural differences among,! Since the 1970s there has been consistent overrepresentation of minority groups are in!
all ethnic minority groups are overrepresented in special education 2021