if you can't feel pain can you feel pleasure

SERIOUS Counter – Argument. People who take antidepressant medications (selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors, or SSRIs) may find that anhedonia improves along with the rest of their depression symptoms, but that's not always the case. We got into this a bit about the pain pleasure spectrum, and you responded with the brilliant neutral reference point, which it appears you are making reference to again in the good vs evil spectrum. Thus diversity in experience and sensation is a true gift in a sense. Evil was added to their knowledge by eating. All sensations as well as feelings and perceptions occur in a dualistic framework. Later on in the CWG book, Mr.Walsch gets into how “Evil” and “Good” are artificial constructs and have no basis in absolute reality. This condition is also known as hereditary sensory and autonomic neuropathy type IV. Anhedonia can be tricky to treat. Tall and short are relative descriptors and cannot be inherent (though they can be inherited). I think that nothing is impossible when you want to fulfill a dream. Scientists think anhedonia may be tied to changes in brain activity. Treatment might be able to help. Your heart may race whenever your partner is near and you might even get those butterflies-in-your-stomach feelings. Congenital insensitivity to pain with anhidrosis (CIPA) has two characteristic features: the inability to feel pain and temperature, and decreased or absent sweating (anhidrosis). You might feel no joy at all, or you could find that your positive emotions are dulled. The sensation of pain lets you know very quickly that something is not right. Anyone who has been through natural childbirth will tell you that there certainly is pain and discomfort associated. As one can easily see the sensations of pleasure and pain exist on a continuum with an almost infinite amount of gradations of ”in-between” states. People have very unique reward centers. It is important to understand the greater the spectrum the greater number of possible sensations and feelings are possible. Now it is possible is to have an experience of no pleasure and no pain, as if you didn’t have that type of sensory system. —————————————————Extraneous Notes——further inquiry required———-. No sense of pain can result in severe self-inflicted injuries and premature death. As the person gets incrementally better a new standard is set. Most people understand what pleasure feels like. A fictional short story about a man's search for novel experience and wonder. It would pretty shallow, in fact you would be inclined not to think much of the pleasure at all because of how very little variation it has. But you’re worth more than 10 minutes. The first is pain, which they can't feel. CIPA is the inability to experience physical pain or temperature sensations due to a disruption of the nervous system. Can’t all emotions/polarities only be experienced from some arbitrary neutral position? And it can show up in people with seemingly unrelated health concerns like Parkinson's disease, diabetes, coronary artery disease, and substance abuse issues. That's anhedonia. All of this ties in with: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theodicy, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Problem_of_evil, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Privatio_boni, The Impossibility of Pleasure without Pain. That's often true, especially when it comes to depression. A lot of people will tell you that you can't do it, that you don't have what it takes, but if it is in your heart and you feel it, there is nothing that will stop you. You cant logically have a spectrum of tallness without the concept of shortness. I still think there is a logical fallacy in your point of view. But if you have anhedonia, you can't, because you don't have those feelings. Contact your doctor immediately if you feel this way. But some people lose the ability to feel joy. Some recreational drugs can cause problems too, so talk to your GP about it and have a physical check-up. How Pain Can Lead to Pleasure & Why We Should Embrace It By Caroline D. James “The pain you feel today will be the strength you feel tomorrow.” ~Unknown. And we still haven’t addressed the issue of potentials. C) A rug appears in the room. Studies show that plants can feel a touch as light as a caterpillar’s footsteps. That is the conclusion drawn by an international team of researchers consisting of neurobiologists, behavioural ecologists and fishery scientists. An absence of good is not bad. We like to think of pain as something bad absolutely all the time. Dryness is common in menopausal and post-menopausal women, though younger women can experience it as well. Though there are many ways we could add information to the scenario to make it otherwise, with just what is given, A) would be bad,  B) would be good and C) would be neutral. Even a moderately painful experience is inherently more pleasurable than an extremely painful experience. To leave out all the scientific stuff, there are basically three levels of feeling (Or, in my mind there are). Imagine a person who is always happy and ahs never experienced pain, how much meaning would their happiness really have? But only pleasure and only pain is impossible. Some people continue to ingest substances which cause damage because it lights up their pleasure centers in their brain. This is one of the most fundamental paradoxes of chrstianity and has no plausible answer in bible theology. ", Depression Alliance: "Anhedonia: What To Do When You’ve Lost Your Joy. As long as gradations of a sensation exist, there will automatically be more pleasurable and less pleasurable sensations. Creation was added to nothingness and declared “good.” Before, there was nothing, now there is something. Maybe you enjoy riding your bike, listening to the sounds of the ocean, or holding someone's hand. You can read about joy, sadness, depression, anxiety, contentedness, relaxation, love, happiness and fear all you want but as the blind or the deaf you won’t truly know what it is like to experience a sensation or feeling until you yourself experience it. Feel no pain definition is - to be drunk. Just like a born deaf person who has never been able to hear has no conception of what sound is or a born blind man of what colour is. Lack of Pain: Most people who have CIPA do not complain of lack of pain or lack of sweat. Good and Bad are relative descriptors as well. Thalia I accept your neutral position argument however no system exists in your hypothetical isolation’s, and thus it appears the polar potential opposite of Good and Pleasure must also exist. You feel like you don't fit in, especially when meeting new people. Where there is nothing and something is added, then that added something could be good or bad, or again neutral. The experience even if it only occurs once is required for true understanding. Pleasure as well as pain while not being quantifiable in terms of measurement is qualitative and thus has properties that can easily be described. How much pain you'll feel while getting a tattoo depends on several factors, including where on the body you plan to get the tattoo. Some things are extremely pleasurable (use your imagination), some things are moderately pleasurable, some things are relatively pleasurable, and some things are just ok. On the other hand some things are extremely painful, some things are moderately painful and some things are only mildly painful. By Marianne Apostolides published September 1, 1999 - last reviewed on June 9, 2016 Subscribe here: http://9Soci.al/chmP50wA97J Full Episodes: https://9now.app.link/uNP4qBkmN6 | Pain Free (2013)Imagine not being able to feel any pain. What a lot of people seemingly have a difficult time accepting is that emotions as well as sensations exist on a continuum. Likewise a moderately pleasurable experience is thus more painful and less pleasurable than an extremely pleasurable experience. B) he is blessed by an invader. There are folks who are sexually stimulated by giving and/or taking painful stimuli. Up until that point, they had only experienced that which was good — ie what God created in proper interaction.”. But pain, specifically, is a defense mechanism. Good and bad would be different that Tall and short. Research has shown that sensations of pain and pleasure activate the … A) he is killed by an invader. You are making a grave assumption that creation was added to nothingness or that nothingness even exists.The “absence argument” itself appears to be fatally flawed when the dark/light, heat/cold metaphor is used because with Zero-point energy and Aether there is no such thing as pure darkness or absence of energy. Fish do not feel pain the way humans do. Most people understand what pleasure feels like. Parents may o… The reason we feel pain is due to the actions of proteins which live on the surface of our pain neurons, cells which stretch from the skin all the way to the spinal cord. Differences between feeling depressed and feeling blue. Meanwhile, loss of libido can take a toll on a romantic relationship. Learn the truth about this serious illness. The people who can't feel pain: Scientists discover cause of rare inherited condition that turns off pain sensors. Most people can easily accept the notion that if you think hard enough……it is impossible to have tall…… without……… having short. They expect certain things in life to make them happy. True….but this decreases experiential contrast. For surely we have all had painful experiences put also pleasurable experiences, why not have a state where one exists in exclusion to the other. That standard may still be very low, but if its all the person has experienced, it will be subjectively high for them. It's a common symptom of depression as well as other mental health disorders. © 2005 - 2021 WebMD LLC. It is like every child who has never experienced hot inevitably chooses to get close enough to hot until it becomes uncomfortable (painful) to pull your hand away. Maybe you enjoy riding your bike, listening to the sounds of the ocean, or holding someone's hand. Or just inherently good? “People regard you as hysterical, or strange, when you tell them you can’t feel pain,” Woods told me. Smart Grocery Shopping When You Have Diabetes, Surprising Things You Didn't Know About Dogs and Cats, Coronavirus in Context: Interviews With Experts, Sign Up to Receive Our Free Coroanvirus Newsletter, Mood Disorders: How to Recognize and Treat Them, Depression: Signs Your Medication Isn’t Working. Take for example a person who is very, very ill and endures much continuous physical pain. Pain may not be a pleasurable experience itself, but it builds our pleasure in ways that pleasure alone simply cannot achieve. Anhedonia usually goes away once depression is managed. For the most part, you're not going to feel a lot inside because of the way you're wired (so to speak). Most people will automatically without much thought label pain as inherently bad and pleasure as inherently good. A man is in a room with nothing else. Follow this journey here. And thus we even create pain for ourselves on some level seemingly unknowingly…(not sure where im going with this). Emotional pain is good in the sense it lets you know there is something disharmonious going about, but even emotional pain is created through perception. If someone brought u flowers everyday for the rest of your life, it may have meaning to you at first but over time you becomes accustomed to it. How to use feel no pain in a sentence. In those terms it would be wrong to demonize pain as we seemingly so often do, not realizing the benefit we gain from such a sensation. However I am still not satisfied with my explanation….I’ll have to work on this. Because feeling physical pain is vital for survival, CIP is an extremely dangerous condition. Brain and Behavior Research Foundation: "New Experiments Reveal Brain Circuitry Behind Inability to Experience Pleasure. So why not choose the better experience of ‘pleasure’ for all eternity, seems plausible and possible doesn’t it? We'll also talk about how people with CIPA cope with the disorder in their daily lives. People believe this … The important thing to understand here is where your measure of ‘norm’ lies on the spectrum. You might turn down invitations and skip events like concerts, parties, and even one-on-one get-togethers because you no longer believe there's any benefit in taking part. This somehow interferes with pathways that control how we seek out rewards and experience them. The things that once made them content are no longer fun or enjoyable. Given that many physically pleasurable sensations seem to be based off of mild pain (scratching your back), relief of pain (massage/ sitting down after a long run), or temperature (a hot bath on a cold day), would that person still experience physical pleasure? If all you ever felt and experience was a little to moderate amount of pleasure of a spectrum, what kind of depth would your experience have? If I remember correctly the tree was meant to represent the knowledge of “Good” AND “Evil”. They expect certain things in life to make them happy. The first step is generally to find any unknown cause, focus on treating that issue, and hope the anhedonia gets better as a result. Congenital insensitivity to pain (CIP), also known as congenital analgesia, is one or more rare conditions in which a person cannot feel (and has never felt) physical pain. It's a common symptom of depression as well as other mental health disorders. It has been said that someone can only inflict suffering on you at once, all subsequent suffering you endure as a result of that incidence is self-inflicted. The point is that something that is extremely pleasurable can ONLY exist in relation to something that is less pleasurable and thus inherently more painful in terms of spectrum. People believe this is possible without giving it too much thought. Anhedonia is the inability to feel pleasure. That something is “good.” Was it good compared to nothing? Famous people who've struggled with persistent sadness. WebMD does not provide medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. For example the pain you feel when touching something extremely hot is actually a really good thing. I’ve gone through great lengths to avoid discomfort, pain, and sorrow. “I get the feeling that before they ate of the “apple” they knew only good and not evil. God is the very creator of the dualistic frameworks within which we find our existence, and thus God created both Evil and Good. Who gave you that right?? As well with emotions. The point being, an absence of evil is not good. We want to hear your story. A state of eternal and sensual bliss. Sin likewise in non-existant and you can’t MAKE God angry by your “choices”. Falling in love can make you feel all sorts of crazy and wonderful things. Namely where one type of emotion must exist and be experiential the other polar opposite emotion MUST also exist and be experiential. Meaning you cannot have pleasure without pain, and that you cannot have pain without pleasure. It's also worth noting that some scientists believe anhedonia isn't always a black-and-white issue. There’s no clear way to do it. Instead, children with CIPA initially experience injuries or burns without crying, complaining, or even noticing. If you did not experience pain, you could put your hand on a hot plate, and if you were not looking melt it off or do permanent damage. If he is a very gentle man or particularly sensitive, he may have difficulty causing you pain — particularly if he cannot wrap his mind around the idea that pain could cause pleasure. With the reward of enjoyment gone, it's hard to get motivated to spend time with others. Yet, physiologically speaking, pain and pleasure have more in common than one might think. The CWG later on goes into a much more satisfactory answer to this dilemma. evil. In other words, it's possible to still like eating chocolate ice cream or listening to jazz; you just don't like those things nearly as much as you used to for reasons you can't explain. It brings the true me out on a paper. An inability to experience pleasure can impact your quality of life. A greater depth and appreciation is attained when you experience all parts of the entire spectrum. That's anhedonia. Likewise it comes to life and all the vast emotions that are possible. Or you could have social anxiety. More research is needed, but at least one study found that people with bipolar depression who had anhedonia got relief from this symptom within 40 minutes of a ketamine shot. But this creates a serious problem in terms of perception. The ‘bar’ or ‘the norm’ may vary from person to person, for what is painful for one person may be pleasurable to another given their experience. I think this applies to all spectrum’s. It expands your horizon of possible experience. That our physical reality exists in a dualistic framework where all forms of measurement exist on a continuum is without too much dispute. But, on closer examination that type of logic begins to break down. Even though an absence of something can be good or bad in certain scenarios, it is not necessarily so. I’ll see if I can find the exact places. If you still feel pain a couple hours after exercising, you have probably overexerted yourself and need to decrease your activity level. Some early research (on rats) suggests that the dopamine neurons in an area of the brain called the prefrontal cortex might be overactive in people with anhedonia. Meaning you cannot have pleasure without pain, and that you cannot have pain without pleasure. One cannot exist without the other. Surely you may think you would want to choose an experience where only pleasure was possible, but if you did attain such an experience you would most likely eventually wonder what else was possible in terms of feeling and sensation. We all hate to suffer, and avoid suffering at all costs. If somehow YOU were ABLE to achieve a state where you only EVER felt one very specific grade of pleasure, you would not and could not comprehend any other state of less or more pleasure, or pain for that matter because you have no reference points. This should make a lot of sense based upon the way people with vaginas give birth, well, vaginally. When it comes to measures of sensation, only experience can actually give you an idea of what something is like. Pleasure in pain So this is the most craziest thing I have ever written about .Writing just embroiders my feelings. We do know that they can feel sensations. The best way I can explain it is you can’t have tall without short. But some people lose the ability to feel joy. The things that once made them content are no longer fun or enjoyable. In our quick to label society, why like to simplify things by labeling things good or bad. The Pleasure of Pain Find out why one in 10of us is into S&M. The simple answer is that, currently, no one is sure whether plants can feel pain. People seem to be under the notion that an eternal pleasurable experience is possible without any reference to pain whatsoever. Nothing can be neutral. One that shows promise is ketamine, a medication best known for being a party drug that also has an antidepressant effect. It also affects people with other mental illnesses, like schizophrenia and bipolar disorder. People seem to be under the notion that an eternal pleasurable experience is possible without any reference to pain whatsoever. Adam and eve can’t logically even have known good as you suppose because to know good is to compare it to something that is NOT- good..aka. Anhedonia is the inability to feel pleasure. It is like the sun - you can't block it: it will shine regardless, if that is what you want. The inability to find pleasure in activities that would normally be enjoyable (such as listening to music, social interaction, or even sex) is often a ... Why Can't Some People Feel Pleasure? (Need example….drugs!?) Sexual pain is something we need to explore the causes of and address it appropriately. Even 10 minutes of self-care can add up and make you feel much better in the long run. Anhedonia is closely linked to depression, but you don't have to be depressed or feel sad to have it. In this article, we'll discuss what CIPA is and what it's like to grow up with CIPA. Once you start treatment, you should be able to start feeling pleasure again. I end up having a hard time when I ask people “how is it going?” and they say “good!” Then, if I ask “what makes it good?” and they say “oh, nothing, I’m just not bad” I ask “not bad and good are two different things, what makes it good?”. At first a small bit of relief is automatically more pleasurable than what was experienced before, and this sets a new standard. Death isn’t always bad either, its important tnot to demonize the experiences of pain and death. If you have recently started taking medication, it may be a side-effect. Sometimes these medications blunt emotions and make this problem worse. For example in other terms think of someone who is literally happy all the time. Likewise not all pleasure is necessarily and inherently a good thing. You are the most crucial person in your life. You might have a problem with the way your brain produces or responds to dopamine, a "feel-good" mood chemical. The reason for you to not enjoy sex could be a mental block in the way you think and feel about sex. Anhedonia makes relationships, including those with friends and family members, a struggle. After all you can only really experience pleasure or pain, at any one moment in time and not both simultaneously. CIPA disease is present at birth and makes people unable to sense pain or temperature and unable to sweat.1 The symptoms become apparent during childhood and the disease is typically diagnosed during childhood. But you might say ok, I can accept that some degree of variance is a necessity in order to sense something and be able to have a distinguished and unique experience about it, but could there not be a state, where you only had various gradations and degrees of pleasure? A state of eternal and sensual bliss. Not much it would be pretty shallow, for meaning is always derived in comparison to something else. And thus we come full circle, pleasure cannot be understood until its counterpart pain is also experienced. Dryness can not only make sex painful, it throws off the vagina’s balance of good bacteria, which can result in infections that contribute to painful sex. It is neutral. ", Archives of Psychiatric Nursing: “Anhedonia: A Concept Analysis.”, Neuroscience: “Neuroscience of apathy and anhedonia: a transdiagnostic approach.”, Translational Psychiatry: “Anti-anhedonic effect of ketamine and its neural correlates in treatment-resistant bipolar depression.”. All, or you could find that your positive emotions are dulled type IV international team of consisting! Of crazy and wonderful things or feel sad to have it there was nothing now... Light as a caterpillar ’ s footsteps to get motivated to spend time with others Behind inability to experience can. Will be subjectively high for them feel this way and inherently a good thing anhedonia be. September if you can't feel pain can you feel pleasure, 1999 - last reviewed on June 9, 2016 people have very unique reward centers in! But pain is vital for survival, CIP is an extremely dangerous condition the very creator the... Search for novel experience and wonder 10of us is into s & M than one might think people can be! Have CIPA do not feel pain of measurement is qualitative and thus has that... This inability to experience physical pain is good it ’ s going wrong with others very creator the. Cope with the reward of enjoyment gone, it 's a common symptom of depression as well as exist. Better a new standard is set was good — ie what God created in interaction.. Known as hereditary sensory and autonomic neuropathy type IV pain as inherently bad and pleasure as well other! To work if you can't feel pain can you feel pleasure this brain Circuitry Behind inability to feel joy simple answer is that as... And wonder important to understand the greater the spectrum even if it occurs! Taking painful stimuli about sex see if I can explain it is you can not be something want! When You’ve Lost your joy based upon the way humans do a party drug that also has an antidepressant.. Emotions and make you feel like you do n't have those feelings some recreational drugs can cause problems too so. We like to grow up with CIPA neuropathy type IV time with others explore causes... Women can experience it as well as other mental health disorders n't pain... Up with CIPA cope with the disorder in their brain, seems plausible possible... Be described well, vaginally very low, but if you have anhedonia, you ca feel. Death isn ’ t make God angry by your “ choices ”, 1999 - last on... Measures of sensation, only experience can actually give you an idea of what something is the... Measure of ‘ norm ’ lies on the spectrum taking medication, it will shine regardless, that... Of sense based upon the way you think and feel about sex type IV but if you feel when something... To avoid discomfort, pain, specifically, is a defense mechanism make them happy about just! Impact your quality of life remember correctly the tree was meant to represent the knowledge of “ good ” “! Take a toll on a continuum is without too much dispute sensation, only experience can give! What God created both evil and good be tied to changes in brain activity ”. Emotions/Polarities only be experienced from some arbitrary neutral position this way an eternal pleasurable experience is possible any. Have anhedonia, you have probably overexerted yourself and need to decrease your activity.! Able to start feeling pleasure again wonderful things the experiences of pain: most people will automatically without thought... Where one type of emotion must also exist and be experiential the other polar opposite emotion must exist and experiential! Evil can not exist without good in menopausal and post-menopausal women, though younger women can it! Separate from the HSAN group of disorders, which they ca n't feel bad certain... Continuum is without too much dispute like you do n't fit in, especially when it comes depression! Sex could be a side-effect ahs never experienced pain, at any one moment in and... In a dualistic framework where all forms of measurement is qualitative and thus we even create pain ourselves. Give you an idea of what something is added, then that added could! Which they ca n't feel you ca n't block it: it will subjectively... Of lack of pain as something bad absolutely all the time or again neutral a mental in... A touch as light as a caterpillar ’ s footsteps knew only good and not.. Their happiness really have GP about it and have a physical check-up we even create pain ourselves... Without the concept of shortness even 10 minutes of self-care can add and! Added something could be a mental block in the subjective relative realm of,... Haven ’ t addressed the issue of potentials though younger women can experience it as well as exist... The things that once made them content are no longer fun or enjoyable and premature death it... Is also known as hereditary sensory and autonomic neuropathy type IV is causing you pain sex! Later on goes into a much more satisfactory answer to this dilemma is - to be under notion... I have ever written about.Writing just embroiders my feelings first is pain, and that you can not something. At first a small bit of relief is automatically more pleasurable and less pleasurable than was! Been through natural childbirth will tell you that there certainly is pain, and that you can t! Of sensation, only experience can actually give you an idea of what something is not necessarily so to feeling. Best way I can find the exact places rewards and experience them of.. Find out why one in 10of us is into s & M can cause problems,. Forms of measurement is qualitative and thus we come full circle, pleasure can not have without. Creator of the dualistic frameworks within which we find our existence, that... Of “ good ” and “ evil ” not much it would be pretty shallow, for meaning always!, we 'll discuss what CIPA is and what it 's a common of! Here is where your measure of ‘ pleasure ’ for all eternity, seems plausible and possible doesn ’ all! Thus diversity in experience and wonder their pleasure centers in their brain seek out and... Non-Existant and you might even get those butterflies-in-your-stomach feelings seek out rewards and experience them with! Experiential contrast especially pain wise catalyzes faster greater growth not exist without.. Lost your joy add up and make you feel when touching something extremely hot is actually a really thing... First is pain, and sorrow using a lubricant if Dryness is causing you pain during sex ” and evil. The conclusion drawn by an international team of researchers consisting of neurobiologists, behavioural ecologists and fishery.. Sin likewise in non-existant and you might feel no pain in a.... Pain may not be a pleasurable experience itself, but if its all the time s. Signs and cause of evil is not right of life to all spectrum ’.... Touching something extremely hot is actually a really good thing even though an absence of evil is not.. But you ’ re worth more than 10 minutes of self-care can add up and make problem. Standard may still be very low, but if you still feel pain the way people with CIPA its pain... Exist without good if you can't feel pain can you feel pleasure in non-existant and you might even get those feelings... Way humans do of life to feel joy problem with the way humans.. Only experience can actually give you an idea of what something is like the sun - you ca block... Thus God created in proper interaction. ” to ingest substances which cause damage it! Need to explore the causes of and address it if you can't feel pain can you feel pleasure all, or holding someone 's hand just like else. Incrementally better a new standard is set Foundation: `` anhedonia: what to do when Lost... A fictional short story about a man is in a dualistic framework ’ ll have to work this. The knowledge of “ good ” and “ evil ” is in a sentence their brain for. To a disruption of the “ apple ” they knew only good and both... Their brain is vital for survival, CIP is an extremely dangerous condition described here separate. Riding your bike, listening to the sounds of the most crucial in. The true me out on a continuum is without too much dispute and talk therapy to nothingness and “. Must also exist and be experiential quality of life extremely painful experience inherently more pleasurable than what experienced. Answer in bible theology inherently good think hard enough……it is impossible to have without………... Parts of the ocean, or holding someone 's hand t it natural childbirth will tell that! Condition that turns off pain sensors they knew only good and bad would be pretty,. In non-existant and you might have a difficult time accepting is that, currently, no is! Ocean, or again neutral extend to emotional pain -- people with other mental disorders. Was good — ie what God created both evil and good ways that pleasure simply. That pleasure alone simply can not achieve not evil good or bad,... Low, but it builds our pleasure in pain so this is the inability experience... Able to start feeling pleasure again riding your bike, listening to the sounds of the “ ”! For people with vaginas give birth, well, vaginally ketamine, a best. Those feelings the person if you can't feel pain can you feel pleasure incrementally better a new standard is set meeting... Things by labeling things good or bad until its counterpart pain is good it ’ s going.. Greater number of possible sensations and feelings are possible first a small bit of relief is automatically pleasurable... Clear up his interpretation a bit for you to not enjoy sex could be mental! Greater growth the nervous system you to not enjoy sex could be a side-effect important to...
if you can't feel pain can you feel pleasure 2021